Thursday, April 8, 2010

M-health, or who will take care of me?


What is the real way to reform Health? asks Eric Wahlgren from DailyFinance, and answers 'Wireless Technology'. The coming convergence of wireless communications, social networking and medicine will transform health care agrees The Economist.

Wireless health (also called mobile health, e-health, m-health or telemedicine) will enable your body parts to make phone calls, your shoes or carpet to consult your doctor , your bed to measure your blood sugar and your phone itself to decide on whether your mental health is deteriorating - based on how quickly you answer the phone and recognize the caller.

No more lies on how much you ate or when you took your last pill. If your heart and other organs are not yet monitored by smart devices, your doctor will listen to your lungs over the phone or check how your knees are doing in 3D.

We are shifting to digital medical era starting from the relatively modest devices to keep you healthy and fit, evolving teletracking, technology, M-health sensors, Telemedicine tools and gadgets, Health 2.0 software tools, and algorithms for health data mining.

There is far more than a list of 101 things to do with a mobile phone in healthcare first compiled a year ago - including simple SMS messaging and GPS-based applications such as Medication Reminders (SMS) and Allergy Alert Service For Asthmatics (SMS and GPS), management of Chronic conditions such as Diabetes, hospital based RFID and the use of technologies such as Bluetooth and ZigBee in health and fitness monitoring.

It's time to take health care off the mainframe says Intel's Eric Dishman in his talk on
behavioral markers, vital sign monitoring and aging care delivery:


Thursday, April 1, 2010

The World of Nutritional Omics

Proteomics and Metabolomics are still lagging behind Genomics, promising to catch up in 5 or 10 years.

Nutriproteomics and Nutrimetabolomics (aka Nutritional Proteomics and Nutritional Metabolomics) may be following the same trend. According to Medline these terms are temporarily forgotten and not yet ready for the prime time.

Nutrigenomics (Nutritional Genomics) is the discipline studying the effects of food on gene expression, thought to bring technologies on tailoring diets to genetic makeups. Many researchers believe that it will also lead to creating foods (so called 'functional foods') that will prevent an individual's genes from expressing disease.

The 2006 report by GeneWatch called nutrigenomics a spin-off from the Human Genome Project created to sell the idea of 'wellness', not for improving health. This report claims that 'Personalized nutrition' is a false solution to the problem of diet-related disease. Most genetic association studies later turn out to be wrong. Genes could contribute to a person's health risks, but the number of other different factors might be overwhelming. According to this report, future health is likely to be much harder to predict than the weather is and basing diets on misleading health predictions could do more harm than good.

With the exception of the major food intolerances (for example, to milk, peanuts, fava beans and alcohol) the body's ability to respond to different diets is complex and likely to be extremely hard to predict from a person's genetic make-up. Aurametrix agrees on this with GeneWatch, but why are the weathermen still employed?.. Aurametrix bases its predictions on the body response to food intake - not only the kind that can be measured by omics technologies, but is acknowledging the importance of genome, proteome and metabolome-based diagnostics.

Like blood pressure and cholesterol levels, but unlike genetic make-up, measurements of gene expression or a person's proteome and metabolome change with time. Researchers are busily tackling transcriptome responses to foods - Dutch ServiceXS, for example, uses microarrays designed by the European Nutrigenomics Organization (NuGo) and manufactured by Affymetrix to study nutrition and genomics.
Nutrition research, on the other hand, is mostly about the isolation and analysis of bioactive components (or nutraceuticals) in foods. At first, it was focused on low molecular weight compounds and single proteins. The rapid growth of molecular biology shifted the focus to DNA, but the great expectations of solving all health-related issues by cracking the genome remained unanswered.

Genes expression does depend on diets, but mRNAs need to be translated into proteins - their sole presence does not guarantee that proteins will be present and working. Genomics fan club defines nutrigenomics as inclusive of all omics disciplines - gene, protein and metabolic profiling, but these are disciplines of their own.
Nutriproteomics studies how diets change expression, modification, distribution and interactions of proteins in the human body. It identifies the protein targets of foods and allows to more accurately than genomics address individual differences in terms of response to diet and food preference. It also helps to assess quality and authenticity of food and is useful for food allergy prevention.
Nutriproteomics addresses not only the qualitative analysis of proteomics interesting to the nutrition scientist, but also protein structures and interactions with other molecules, proteomes specific to body fluids and their localization in tissues.

In our previous blogs, we talked about metabolomics, genomics and molecular dietetics. Nutrimetabolomics focuses on the metabolomic aspect of nutritional phenotype, exploring the human response to different nutritional situations. It is estimated that there are 6,500 individual metabolites produced in the human body. Subtle disruptions in metabolic processes are evident in easily accessed body fluids and vapors. Nutrimetabolomics is nothing short of biochemical oracle for nutrition promising to accelerate the discovery of new markers and diet-related pathways. Quantitative measures of small molecules or metabolites can tell about deficiencies of digestive enzymes, microbiome health, best nutrition methods to improve individual health. Individual metabolic phenotypes do exist and can be defined from multiple measurements after eliminating the daily "noise".

The “Nutritional Phenotype database” (dbNP) was proposed to integrate and interrogate genetics, transcriptomics, proteomics, biomarkers, metabolomics, functional assays, food intake and food composition data, tailored to nutrition research and embedded in an environment of standard procedures and protocols, curated by the Nutrigenomics Organisation (NuGo). dbNP is extensively described in a publication in Genes & Nutrition 2010. It's based on micronutrient data sheets, comprehensive pathways (see examples for folate and selenium in the micronutrient portal ), ontologies and other knowledge engineering and analytic technologies.

Other Links
Aurametrix goal is to provide powerful solutions at your fingertips to help you manage your health. The company is initially focusing on relief for those suffering from digestive problems.
Enhanced by Zemanta

Sunday, March 28, 2010

Health Data, Self-serve, Visualization, Semantic Analysis and Collective Intelligence

Notes from the Biomedical Data Mining Camp Session led by Dr. Irene Gabashvili and other health-related discussions at Data Mining Camp and Transparency Camp 2010.

The title for the session was "Biomedical Data Mining: Successes, Failures, and Challenges" (streamed online from Fireside C).
The topic stemmed from the similarly named last year's session - Biomedical Data Mining: Dimensionality, Noise, Applications - now split into several discussions including Bioinformatics & Genome Sequencing organized by Raymond McCauley, Dimensionality Reduction moderated by Luca Rigazio (HLDA / HDA; LDPP; Core Vector Machines; Sparse Proj SQ; Random Projection and Feature Selection).

Main sub-topics of the biomedical session were:
  • Reality Mining
  • Visualization
  • Imaging
  • Signal Processing
Reality mining is expected to improve public health and medicine. It was named as one of "10 emerging technologies that could change the world". This is not only about mining data pertaining to social behavior - although social factors do impact well-being and social data provides valuable health predictors. It's also about health data collected in real and near real time. Audience asked about ways to collect health data and their limitations. Some of the questions reflected earlier Q&A with the Data Mining Camp expert panel , especially Dr. Michael Walker, author of numerous FDA and CLIA-approved products to diagnose and treat disease. He commented on the need to have tools well beyond the data available to take cell samples every two minutes instead of laboratory testing every few months - in order to allow cellular simulations and obtain parameters for differential equations. Sampling frequencies don't come close to allow this kind of modeling. Irene Gabashvili agreed that first-principles cellular modeling for predicting health won't be possible (although there are engineers that believe a platform for real-time in-vivo measurements of most cells can be developed). Yet, good predictors could be and will be developed - based on sensors measuring macro-level observations and missing value estimators. Genetic information is not enough, we need to capture environmental risk factors. How can we separate genes and environment?, asked one of the participants. Aurametrix' initial focus is on chemicals in our food - and even though some may argue that our taste and satiety mechanisms are dictated by genes, food analytics provides insights into non-genetic components of our health. Other questions were on the time line for body sensor networks and data growth. Jeffrey Nick of EMC estimates that personal sensor data will balloon from 10% of all stored information to 90% within the next decade. Irene Gabashvili thinks that this will happen rather sooner than later, perhaps in the next two years.

Another interesting aspect of reality mining is crowdsourcing or collective intelligence - in order to get useful information from all the data (temporospatial location, GPS, activity, food, symptoms, behavior, communication content, proximity sensing), we need to analyze it not only on individual but also group level. We need to share more, without sacrificing privacy and security. Collective contributions can be reliable - Shamod Lacoui's answer to this is in selecting those who contribute, restricting inputs to domain. It would help to “filter out the dross”, while “saving the best”. It is needed to suppress noise, to infer intelligence from the collection of facts, clicks, steps, whatever one can contribute. This resonates with discussions at the Transparency Camp - one of the useful tools is SwiftRiver - free, open source software platform to validate and filter news. Swift relies on Natural Language Processing, Machine Learning and Veracity Algorithms to track and verify the accuracy of reports and suppress noise (like duplicate content, irrelevant cross-chatter and inaccuracies). Transparency Camp also posed a question on whether there is a need for an FDA-like institution to ensure information safety and healthy information consumption.

Self-serve was a topic of a smaller Data Mining Camp Session. Even though it was aimed at sales reps that need to go beyond Excel spreadsheets to mine private data of their interest, self-service is currently the only option for health care consumers. People need to analyze everyday life for health implications. They need better tools to not focus on metrics that are easy to collect instead of metrics we need to collect.

In order to mine high-dimensional health space, many disparate types of data should be mashed and validated, gaps should be bridged and structured metadata added to data. Randy Kerber talked about data formats and approaches to make it happen. Semantic web discussions involved NoSQL experts that mentioned limitations of gaining popularity technologies such as MongoDB, Cassandra and HBase. Another relevant session - on cloud computing - discussed its (sometimes over-rated ?) performance and Hadoop technologies.

Visualization techniques provide one of the most effective methods of extracting knowledge from health data. Remember who invented the pie chart? That's right, it was Florence Nightingale, a nurse who needed a way to better represent her data. one of the most famous examples of visualizing epidemiological data was Dr. John Snow's map of deaths from a cholera outbreak in London, Many other techniques and software tools exist, but maps remain popular - especially google maps API. One of popular tools for epidemiological data is Google Maps API. For example, it embeds Google Maps into healthmap.org with JavaScript.

One of the participants of Biomedical Session developed kidsdata.org (@kidsdata on twitter). It provides insights into geospatial autism statistics and visualizes trends and other useful health-related information.

Another way to display geospatial data is Dynamic Choropleth Maps. Complex networks can be also explored with alluvial diagrams and other approaches. More visualization techniques and tools can be applied to health data - to look at the data in new ways and gain useful insights.

Some of the questions from the audience were on the availability of data. Sources discussed included CDC (see, for example, NHANES laboratory files; eHealth metrics) and Entrez Life Sciences databases.

Signal Detection and Signal Processing for Mining Information was another discussion topic.
Questions were on data mining versus simple tracking and signal monitoring. It was agreed that data mining is the key to health management. Cardionet, body sensors (see posts on teletracking, M-health, Telemedicine: part 1; Telemedicine: part 2; Health 2.0 Software tools, Devices to keep you healthy), SNP detection, telemedicine applications, random and rare electrocardiographic events and other applications were also discussed.




See other materials from Data mining Camp 2010:


Reblog this post [with Zemanta]
blockquote { margin:1em 20px; background: #dfdfdf; padding: 8px 8px 8px 8px; font-style: italic; }